Reporting While Running Toward Danger

by Allie on April 16, 2013

“There are three kinds of people who run toward disaster, not away: cops, firemen and reporters.” -Rod Dreher, newspaper columnist

I saw this quote on the wall at the Newseum in Washington DC this past autumn, just days before the anniversary of September 11th. While the quote is not entirely accurate, as evidenced by all the people who ran towards the explosions to help others yesterday at the Boston Marathon, it does draw attention to a set of people who often go under-appreciated during crises: journalists.

Journalists provide a public service; their job is to report and inform, bringing knowledge and answers to their audience. In the case of visual journalists, they also take on the role of being the eyes of the viewers. It’s often easy to overlook what they do, or forget that they perform their jobs at their own risk during a crisis. It’s easy to assume that they are detached from a situation as the cover tragedies too, but the reality is this: journalists covering these events are in the midst of a balancing act. They are balancing performing their job while processing the same events they are experiencing. They are balancing getting the news while being sensitive to the victims.

In today’s Boston Globe, columnist Kevin Cullen recognizes this balancing act, writing:

I saw Lisa Hughes from WBZ-TV trying to do her job, amid the blood and the body parts. And then I remembered that Lisa, who is as nice a person as you’ll find in this business, married a guy from Wellesley named Mike Casey who lost his wife Neilie on one of the planes out of Boston that crashed into the Twin Towers. And then I tried not to cry and just marveled at how professional Lisa was.

This balancing act is what struck me the most at the Newseum’s 9/11 exhibit. The film “Running Toward Danger” shares first-person accounts from journalists covering the events of September 11th– how they were reporting one minute and running for their lives the next, trying to perform their jobs but then breaking down and crying while trying to process what had just happened. It’s a story that is resounded in Time’s Q&A with Boston Globe photographer John Tlumacki does a really great job of illuminating what one photojournalist experienced while working an event like yesterday’s. Tlumacki says “you try not to get your emotions involved as a photographer” and describes sticking to the job and exercising good judgement. Then he says:

I was so shook up about it — I was speechless when I was there [on scene]. My eyes were swelling up behind my camera. We use a camera as a defense but I was shaken when I got back, just scanning the pictures. The other sad part was that I took my shoes off because they were covered in blood from walking on the sidewalk taking pictures.

I always wondered what it would be like when I see photographers covering this stuff all over the world. You go to Israel and then there’s an explosion and photographers are there. It’s haunting to be a journalist and have to cover it. I don’t ever want to have to do that again.

According to Al Tompkins of the Poynter Institute for Media Studies, journalists’ symptoms of traumatic stress are remarkably similar to those of police offers and firefighters who deal with tragedies. Yet unlike other first responders, journalists seldom receive support such as debriefings and counseling, Tompkins says.

The mental risks are just one component of covering trauma. There’s also the risk of personal injury or death. In the United States, only one journalist has died as a result of a dangerous assignment since the Committee to Protect Journalists started keeping track in 1992. That one journalist was Bill Biggart, a freelance photojournalist who died during the September 11th attacks. Biggart was walking his dog when he learned that a plane had hit the World Trade Center. He ran home, grabbed his camera, and rushed to the scene. At 10:28:24 AM, he took his last shot, before the second tower collapsed, killing him. Biggart’s body was recovered in the rubble four days later, along with three cameras, six rolls of film, and one compact flash card containing nearly 150 digital images. As I walked around the Newseum and saw the images from Biggart’s final moments next to his battered gear, I broke down and cried.

Biggart is just one of 123 journalists who have died on dangerous assignments around the world since 1992, and another 856 have died in connection with their work as a result of murder or combat.

So today while we reflect on yesterday’s events and the brave people who put themselves in harm’s way, let us think of the journalists as well, not just in Boston, but around the world.

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

A lion in a fenced private reserve in South Africa. Copyright: Allie Wilkinson

To fence, or not to fence: that is the question:
Whether ’tis nobler for lions to suffer
The slings and arrows of outraged farmers,
Or to take measures against the wrath of men,
And by fencing protect them?

Conservation biologists have long debated whether wildlife, and carnivores in particular, should be managed through landscape approaches or through physical separation (i.e. fences). The case for carnivores lends itself to fencing them in; populations of large carnivores are decreasing around the world, and conflict with humans is a big problem. Large carnivores range far and wide, making it nearly impossible to avoid coming into close proximity to humans at some point in their lives. With livestock lost to tooth and claw, and personal safety at risk, humans are generally not happy about sharing space with carnivores. Conservation efforts try to decrease the stress of cohabitation with compensation schemes, such as those that offer economic incentives to farmers and ranchers for lost livestock– bribery at its finest.

The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our lions, but in ourselves.

Over the past 100 years, habitat loss has reduced the lion’s range by 75 percent, which has only intensified human-lion conflicts. Poorly regulated sport hunting has resulted in over-harvesting in some areas. Add to that mix genetically isolated populations, which leads to inbreeding and all the troubles that come with it–such as reduced reproductive rates and greater susceptibility to disease– and it’s not a pretty picture for lions.

Yet not all lion populations have declined. Lions in the Serengeti have increased steadily over the past half-century, and populations have remained stable in several large South African national parks. Private game reserves in South Africa and Zimbabwe have had success in restoring lion populations to their former glory before they went locally extinct. The secret to success in South Africa’s national parks (and I suspect many of the private reserves) is fencing; all of South Africa’s national parks are fenced in. Lions are considered so dangerous in South Africa that they can only be re-introduced after wildlife managers erect lion-proof fencing and agree to recapture or destroy any escaping lions. The fences are effective at preventing most conflicts between lions and humans, but it runs against the conservation ethic of keeping protected areas unfenced. Another issue is that many countries in the lions’ range have policies against fencing.

It might be time to change those policies. Nearly half of Africa’s free-roaming lion populations are expected to decline to the point of near-extinction over the next 20 to 40 years, according to a new study published in Ecology Letters. By looking at lion population densities and trends in comparison to management techniques, they found that lions in fenced reserves fare better, with population levels closer to the number of lions that the environment can sustain. Fencing in lions also makes more sense financially: you get more bang for your buck, or in this case, lions for your dollar. Fenced reserves maintained 80 percent of the lion population they could sustainably support at $500 per square kilometer; unfenced populations cost $2000 per square kilometer and only support half the amount of lions the land could sustain.

While enclosing lions isn’t ideal, it is effective– and may also be just the thing conservation efforts need to maintain intact savannah ecosystems. Carnivores and healthy ecosystems go hand-in-hand. Top-level predators help keep the balance of nature, and their loss can have disastrous consequences: altering landscapes, impacting ecosystem dynamics, and generally causing mayhem.

In sub-Sarahan Africa, the decline of lions has led to a dramatic increase in olive baboons, which has intensified conflict between humans and baboons. As baboons become more brazen in their crop-raiding, families resort to taking their children out of school to help guard the fields. So while living with lions may come with its fair share of headaches, humans are a lot better off living with them than living without them.

Packer C., Loveridge A., Canney S., Caro T., Garnett S.T., Pfeifer M., Zander K.K., Swanson A., MacNulty D. & Balme G. & (2013). Conserving large carnivores: dollars and fence, Ecology Letters, n/a-n/a. DOI:

{ 5 comments }

A beginner’s guide to Pinterest

March 7, 2013

Last night I gave a talk with Denise Graveline on using Pinterest for science writers, an event hosted by Science Writers in New York and the American Society of Journalists and Authors. (If you missed it, ASJA has an archive of the event.) Denise has shared her slides and recapped the event on her blog, explaining [...]

Read the full article →

Goodbye Green: The State of Environmental Coverage

March 4, 2013

As you may have gathered from my prior post on the matter, I was very upset when the New York Times closed its environment desk seven weeks ago– fearing that environmental coverage would take a hit at the Times, and that the decision would send the message to other outlets that environmental coverage isn’t a [...]

Read the full article →

Freelancers Anonymous Support Group: Conquering Your Freelance Fears

February 7, 2013

Helpful tips from “”The art, craft and business of freelancing” session at ScienceOnline 2013, moderated by Maggie Koerth-Baker (@maggiekb1) and Charles Choi (@cqchoi). View the story “Freelancers Anonymous Support Group: Conquering Your Freelance Fears” on Storify

Read the full article →

Asbury H. Sallenger Jr., Renowned Oceanographer, Dies at 63

February 6, 2013

Asbury “Abby” H. Sallenger Jr., research oceanographer at the U.S. Geological Survey and expert on hurricanes and coastal-change, passed away at his home in Pinellas County, Florida last night. He was 63. “Abby was an imaginative researcher and was engaged in his own research, and in the broader community, until the end,” wrote John W. [...]

Read the full article →